Story and Evidence, a Response
      

I think it goes to my larger point.  Story moves.  Yes, Story can move more than evidence.  And yet even if that is the case, nowhere do I suggest that I think that is good!    Indeed, this whole event illustrates just how unfortunate it can be when evidence is divorced from Story.  Oh yes, there is a Story here.  There is a Narrative.  This Narrative is one that Myers and his many fans are drenched in, so much so none of them actually need evidence to know that me and my stories are [fill in your favorite pejoratives here].  The Narrative fills in the gap.  It is the skeptical storyline:  Christians, dumb.  Christians, blind faith.  Skeptics, geniuses.  Skeptics, reason and evidence.  Nothing more needs to be said because everyone is already agreed on how the story ends, anyway.  The 'evidence' ends up being just a 'literary' flourish that adds little to the accepted Narrative.

This Narrative appears to be driving Dave's response, though to his credit, he is exceptionally mild and measured compared to many of the other responses I observed.
         

http://sntjohnny.com/front/story-and-evidence-a-response/1437.html