Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Big Brother row  (Read 639 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Dannyboy

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +18/-3
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 854
Big Brother row
« on: January 30, 2007, 09:53:47 AM »

Don't know if our American cousins will have caught this.

The recent series of the UK version of the TV show 'Big Brother' (which i believe also gets inflicted on Americans) has stirred up a storm of controversy, and i'm sort of at a loss to know why.  Being the anti-social iconoclast that i am, i have no TV, so i've been following this frenzy in newspapers and the lunch-time discussions of my work colleagues.  Incidentally, can anyone think of anything much more stupid that the western world has created than one form of media reporting on what is happening on another form of media?

Anyway.

This is a 'celebrity' Big Brother series, which as far as i can see is a euphemism for people you had never heard of, but who once appeared on TV, or at least slept with someone or are related to someone who did.  Michael Jackson's brother is on it.  Wow.  Also appearing is a woman called Jade Goody, who became famous for being almost unbelievably stupid and ignorant on one of the non-'celebrity' Big Borther series', and who the media have adopted as being in some way lovable and cute in her terminal denseness.  Bizarrely, she's pretty much the most famous person in the program in the UK, or was (but i'm getting to that).

Also in the house is/was an Indian Bollywood star, who i'd never heard of before called Shilpa Shetty - very attractive lady from her picture.  It is unlikely that the producers didn't forsee conflict between this high-caste well-spoken (by all accounts) woman and the likes of Jade, who has made a virtue out of being ignorant and crass.  As it turns out, there's a couple more like her (Jade) in the house, so of course they've ganged up on Shilpa with some borderline racial abuse and bullying which has been widely greeted by the press with hands thrown up in horror.  Obviously, no one saw this coming.

Jade got evicted fairly early, unsurprisingly, to be met by a barrage of focussed hatred from the media far more brutal than what she was accused of.  i just read that she's checked into some sort of therapy-retreat place to escape it and deal with her resultant depression.  Her overnight (from her point of view) transformation from the icon of lovable goofs everywhere to an internationally reviled race-hate figure must have come as a bit of a shock.  Apparently they've been burning efigies of her in India, which is about the same level of intelligent debate as has been had in most British newspapers.

Shilpa, of course, has won the event, and emerged from the house with her previously non-existent UK fame unshakably established.

i realise at this stage of the post that i have no particular point to make, plus i really need to get on with tidying my flat, but i thought i'd see whether any of this 'news' had reached the US.

it's weird.   :?
Logged
If God has a problem with the way i live my life then let him tell me, not you.

"Denying your own experience of reality is never a good step, no matter how many are arrayed against you" - Spero by AR Horvath

Copernicus

  • Paramount User!!
  • *
  • Feedback: +30/-18
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2226
    • Naastika Blog
Re: Big Brother row
« Reply #1 on: January 30, 2007, 03:35:07 PM »

Actually, I read quite a bit about this while I was in India (December 28 thru January 22).  My own opinion is that the developers of the show scripted much of what went on, but they had misjudged how serious the reaction would be.  What they did get was a huge bump in their sagging ratings, but they also got a bit of a black eye.  Clearly, Shilpa and the others were coached to make up with each other after the matter had become an international incident.  Jade Goody admitted as much in an interview after she was voted off the show.  Reality shows have the same pressures on them as TV game shows.  They need to be interesting enough to keep the ratings up, so there must be tremendous temptation to spunk up the action by coaching the involved parties.  TV game shows have been caught cheating at this before, so I wouldn't be surprised if it were endemic in the "reality TV" genre.
« Last Edit: January 30, 2007, 03:37:33 PM by Copernicus »
Logged
Philosophy is questions that may never be answered.  Religion is answers that may never be questioned.  --Anonymous

Dannyboy

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +18/-3
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 854
Re: Big Brother row
« Reply #2 on: January 30, 2007, 04:06:12 PM »

Yeah, the whole thing reminded me of the blame game that get's played by the British media and the viewing/reading public with particularly crass or offensive stories.  OR, of course, even more strongly when the press is actually implicated in a news story - Diana's death was the best example.

The public and the media feed each other, but when something like this happens they both come up with lillywhite innocent chants of "We were only watching what was on" and "We only provide what the public wants" respectively.

There was a great Private Eye cover in the week after Diana's death.  It had a picture of the hundreds of people mourning in front of Buckingham palace, with three speech bubbles rising from anonymous heads within the crowd:

"What a terrible tragedy - i blame the press"
"Me too, come to think of it, i havent seen a paper today"
"Do you want to look at mine - it's got a picture of the car!"

As far as i remember it was withdrawn after widespread complaints of insensitivity.  Funny that. [smile
Logged
If God has a problem with the way i live my life then let him tell me, not you.

"Denying your own experience of reality is never a good step, no matter how many are arrayed against you" - Spero by AR Horvath
Pages: [1]   Go Up