Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?  (Read 2957 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Anthony Horvath

  • Administrator
  • sntjohnny? I'm sntjohnny!
  • *
  • Feedback: +28/-41
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8493
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« on: October 22, 2005, 11:39:21 PM »

This is a topic I haven't probed in a long time.  I seem to recall it coming up on the old DTF forum (before most of your's times) but not since.  So, it may be worth reviving it, at least.

Is 'unconditional love' real?  If real, is it good?
Logged
Today's Favorite Quote:  "The UN is like GI Joe - an organization with the goal of world peace. Difference being one of them actually achieves their goals."  EndBringer

Yesterday's Fav: "I love when it all comes down to semantics, because that usually means I get to pwn someone."  Sir Somebody Something, Deep Truth, Trent, Solaris Paradox

Heretic

  • Prevalent User
  • *
  • Feedback: +3/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1057
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #1 on: October 23, 2005, 08:08:36 AM »

Heck no! There is no such thing as "unconditional" love. Love always has conditions on it.  Whether it be blood-relations, a monetary pay-off or just plain sexual satisfaction there is some type, at some level a condition attached to it. JMO 8)
Logged
Silly Christians. Myths are for kids! [baby

If there are no Atheists in foxholes then WTF was I doing there?!

 Certainty of death, small chance of success? What are we waiting for?! --Gimli the Dwarf

I am perfectly happy to say that gods are a logical possibility. There is just no reasonable evidence to license such a belief. --Copernicus

SoughtFound&Alive

  • Regular User
  • *
  • Feedback: +0/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 139
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #2 on: October 23, 2005, 02:40:40 PM »

It seems to me that consistent unconditional would only be possible by a perfect God.  Humans are wired with too much selfishness to unconditionally love all the time.
Logged
Is it ALL meaningless?

Ragnar

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 888
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #3 on: October 24, 2005, 09:58:28 PM »

I always think it best to look at the most extreme case you can think of to see if propositions like this hold.

For this example, let's say you think you love your wife unconditionally. If she were to hold your children at gunpoint and threatened to kill them, and you had the opportunity to kill her before she did this, would you? If so, then I would say at that point you no longer love her. So even if the only condition on your love is that she never hold your children at gunpoint, that's still a condition.

Therefore, the love is not unconditional.
Logged
[batman

"My philosophy, in essence, is the concept of man as a heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute."  
- Ayn Rand

"Mastering others is strength. Mastering yourself makes you fearless."
- Lao Tzu

"Your side hates our side because you think we think you're stupid. Our side hates your side because we think you're stupid."
- Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip

SoughtFound&Alive

  • Regular User
  • *
  • Feedback: +0/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 139
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #4 on: October 25, 2005, 08:32:29 AM »

I wouldn't be so quick to make that assumption.  Protecting your childrens' lives doesn't necessarily equivocate losing love for your wife because you had to harm her.
Logged
Is it ALL meaningless?

Anthony Horvath

  • Administrator
  • sntjohnny? I'm sntjohnny!
  • *
  • Feedback: +28/-41
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8493
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #5 on: October 25, 2005, 10:54:44 AM »

I agree with SF that there are some unspoken assumptions here that need to be worked through.  I'd like to make my own point, though.

In negating the 'unconditional love' for your wife, didn't you affirm it in this scenario for your children?  Didn't you establish the possibility of the very thing your exampe was supposed to demonstrate?
Logged
Today's Favorite Quote:  "The UN is like GI Joe - an organization with the goal of world peace. Difference being one of them actually achieves their goals."  EndBringer

Yesterday's Fav: "I love when it all comes down to semantics, because that usually means I get to pwn someone."  Sir Somebody Something, Deep Truth, Trent, Solaris Paradox

Ragnar

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 888
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #6 on: October 25, 2005, 03:34:04 PM »

Quote from: sntjohnny
I agree with SF that there are some unspoken assumptions here that need to be worked through.  I'd like to make my own point, though.

In negating the 'unconditional love' for your wife, didn't you affirm it in this scenario for your children?  Didn't you establish the possibility of the very thing your exampe was supposed to demonstrate?


That's true, to a certain extent. You can have unconditional love for your children up to a certain age, I think. I think when they start thinking for themselves conditions might arise. Under extreme conditions, I think it would not be good to love your grown children unconditionally. Of course it is possible that people love unconditionally, but to answer your second question, I don't think it is good.
Logged
[batman

"My philosophy, in essence, is the concept of man as a heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute."  
- Ayn Rand

"Mastering others is strength. Mastering yourself makes you fearless."
- Lao Tzu

"Your side hates our side because you think we think you're stupid. Our side hates your side because we think you're stupid."
- Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip

TheAtheistHeratic

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +1/-5
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 878
  • Its a tuxedo
    • Myspace
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #7 on: October 25, 2005, 03:37:02 PM »

I unconditionally love myself.
Logged
"Religion is an insult to human dignity. With or without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion." (Washington, D.C., April 1999) [2]

"One of the great achievements of science has been, if not to make it impossible for intelligent people to be religious, then at least to make it possible for them not to be religious. We should not retreat from this accomplishment." (ibid.)
[edit]

Both quotes of Steven Weinberg

Anthony Horvath

  • Administrator
  • sntjohnny? I'm sntjohnny!
  • *
  • Feedback: +28/-41
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8493
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #8 on: October 25, 2005, 07:22:42 PM »

:smt078
Logged
Today's Favorite Quote:  "The UN is like GI Joe - an organization with the goal of world peace. Difference being one of them actually achieves their goals."  EndBringer

Yesterday's Fav: "I love when it all comes down to semantics, because that usually means I get to pwn someone."  Sir Somebody Something, Deep Truth, Trent, Solaris Paradox

rareairpug

  • Administrator
  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-1
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 922
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #9 on: October 25, 2005, 07:53:53 PM »

Sadly, that might be close to the truth.  I'm sure that there are many people who would do anything for themselves, no?
Logged

Ragnar

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 888
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #10 on: October 25, 2005, 08:11:17 PM »

That's actually an interesting spin on the topic. Do you love yourself unconditionally? I definitely don't. There are goals I want to meet and standards that I try to hold myself to, based on my chosen philosophy. Without meaning to make Johnny hurl again  :)   I love myself only as long as I do everything I can to contribute to my own happiness.
Logged
[batman

"My philosophy, in essence, is the concept of man as a heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute."  
- Ayn Rand

"Mastering others is strength. Mastering yourself makes you fearless."
- Lao Tzu

"Your side hates our side because you think we think you're stupid. Our side hates your side because we think you're stupid."
- Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip

rareairpug

  • Administrator
  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-1
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 922
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #11 on: October 25, 2005, 08:23:40 PM »

But if you are doing everything you can to contribute to your happiness---isn't that unconditional love in itself?
Logged

Ragnar

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 888
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #12 on: October 26, 2005, 10:07:44 AM »

Quote from: rareairpug
But if you are doing everything you can to contribute to your happiness---isn't that unconditional love in itself?


Hmm, perhaps. But that would only hold if I actually do everything I can that is in my own best interests. I admittedly don't, and I would say that at those times I do not love myself. Conditions always exist in one way or another.
Logged
[batman

"My philosophy, in essence, is the concept of man as a heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute."  
- Ayn Rand

"Mastering others is strength. Mastering yourself makes you fearless."
- Lao Tzu

"Your side hates our side because you think we think you're stupid. Our side hates your side because we think you're stupid."
- Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip

Anthony Horvath

  • Administrator
  • sntjohnny? I'm sntjohnny!
  • *
  • Feedback: +28/-41
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8493
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #13 on: October 26, 2005, 10:28:11 AM »

I don't know how you can say that once you've already conceded that part of the argument when you said:  "You can have unconditional love for your children up to a certain age, I think"

Wasn't the point of that analogy to stretch things to their extreme?  If it really is the extreme case, then the reality of unconditional love has been established between us, and the better question is to discuss whether it is 'good' or not.
Logged
Today's Favorite Quote:  "The UN is like GI Joe - an organization with the goal of world peace. Difference being one of them actually achieves their goals."  EndBringer

Yesterday's Fav: "I love when it all comes down to semantics, because that usually means I get to pwn someone."  Sir Somebody Something, Deep Truth, Trent, Solaris Paradox

Ragnar

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +2/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 888
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #14 on: October 26, 2005, 01:45:06 PM »

Okay. Yes, of course it exists, because people are capable of it. I said I do not think it is good. This is because once you grant someone unconditional love then you might be willing to do things for that person that you otherwise wouldn't do. This can include "bad" things, or perhaps more precisely, irrational things. When you grant unconditional love, if someone changes, it may be hard to see them for what they really are.
Logged
[batman

"My philosophy, in essence, is the concept of man as a heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute."  
- Ayn Rand

"Mastering others is strength. Mastering yourself makes you fearless."
- Lao Tzu

"Your side hates our side because you think we think you're stupid. Our side hates your side because we think you're stupid."
- Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip

TheAtheistHeratic

  • Predominant User
  • *
  • Feedback: +1/-5
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 878
  • Its a tuxedo
    • Myspace
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #15 on: October 26, 2005, 02:53:47 PM »

If you don't unconditionally love yourself you would not try to help yourself.  Just because you punish "fill in the blank" does not mean you don't love " fill in this blank as the one before" still.
Logged
"Religion is an insult to human dignity. With or without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion." (Washington, D.C., April 1999) [2]

"One of the great achievements of science has been, if not to make it impossible for intelligent people to be religious, then at least to make it possible for them not to be religious. We should not retreat from this accomplishment." (ibid.)
[edit]

Both quotes of Steven Weinberg

Heretic

  • Prevalent User
  • *
  • Feedback: +3/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1057
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #16 on: October 27, 2005, 08:15:49 AM »

I unconditionally love myself.


Yeah me too. 3 or 4 times daily. [harry
(HEY!! I just saw the name of that smiley! I'm insulted!! :wink: )

Ok ok ok ok ok..... how about this:  

One of your children has become a suicide bomber at the age of 3. He/she is running into a crowd of other small children, you could stop the massacre but you would have to kill your child.

Would you do it? If yes could you still claim unconditional love for your child as in the idea AH/Anti seems to be promoting?

I still say no, it does not exist.  In the child examples given, the condition is still "Because they're your child".  


  [atheistheretickly
Logged
Silly Christians. Myths are for kids! [baby

If there are no Atheists in foxholes then WTF was I doing there?!

 Certainty of death, small chance of success? What are we waiting for?! --Gimli the Dwarf

I am perfectly happy to say that gods are a logical possibility. There is just no reasonable evidence to license such a belief. --Copernicus

Anthony Horvath

  • Administrator
  • sntjohnny? I'm sntjohnny!
  • *
  • Feedback: +28/-41
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8493
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #17 on: October 27, 2005, 08:24:35 AM »

I would kill my child.

THere seems to be this unspoken assumption that love absolutely always requires doing no harm.  Not only is this not the Christian view, parents the world over throughout all times know that sometimes love requires them to do things that inflict pain on their children.

We could take this to the ridiculous (Ragnar's Extreme) and suggest that anyone who truly unconditionally loves their child would do everything in their power to serve them.  Thus, when it comes time when most babies learn to walk, you serve the child by carrying it wherever it wants.  Now, you don't have to worry about it expending any useless energy, and you also don't have to worry about the baby falling and hurting itself on living room furnature, or possibly wandering out of eye sight and falling off something- like stairs, maybe.

Does unconditional love require parents to physically carry their 10 year old child?  Their 20 year old child?

This is silly, but the whole process of learning to walk can be a painful one, and yet it would NOT be loving to save them from that pain.
Logged
Today's Favorite Quote:  "The UN is like GI Joe - an organization with the goal of world peace. Difference being one of them actually achieves their goals."  EndBringer

Yesterday's Fav: "I love when it all comes down to semantics, because that usually means I get to pwn someone."  Sir Somebody Something, Deep Truth, Trent, Solaris Paradox

Wholly Polterquist

  • Regular User
  • *
  • Feedback: +0/-0
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 81
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Unconditional love
« Reply #18 on: October 27, 2005, 09:47:21 AM »

"I met a prominant, well respected psychologist, many years ago, that had the very same feelings on this subject as you do. This man had several children, and because, he had much training in the therapeutical craft, he along with his collegues, had convinced themselves, that they were, the cream of the crop, when it came to love, discipline, relationships, and parenting. One of the stories, that he so proudly related to me, is this: On one occasion, this man, chose to take his children, on a nature walk. Before he took his chargees, out of the house, he had a bit of a dilemna, with his five year old daughter. His wife, had just purchased a new pair of shoes, for the little girl, and she wanted to wear them on the walk. This man, explained to his childe, that she needed to put on her older, worn in shoes, before they went walking, because these new shoes, would end up hurting her feet, and she would then want to be carried, and he was not going to carry her. The little girl, who did not have the understanding that her father had in this area, could not comprehend, that these new shoes, that at present were not hurting her feet, could cause her such discomfort, when used on a long walk. She stubbornly rejected her fathers advice, and chose to wear her new shoes anyway. Soon the family made it to the trail, where they were going for their hike, and just as the father had predicted, the little girl, became very, very uncomfortable in her new shoes. Every step, began producing sores, and blisters, to her little feet, and her father, staying very steadfast, in his disciplinary proceedures, ignored her pleas and cries for help, refusing, to carry the child. He was the man. He was in charge. And she knew, the master. What did this man actually teach his little girl, and what has he taught the many, many families, who have passed under his thresh hold? This is just one example of this man and his inhueman agenda. How many generations, of individuals, have been adversely effected, by the dangerous instructions of this one man? And how many fragile spirits, will continue to be adversely desecrated, and destroyed by this very subtle, yet very popular form of toxicity, and poison? What do you think?"

Moste Sincerely,
Wholly Polterguiste
Logged
Be aware: "Though dead men, tell no tales, the living who were once pronounced dead among you, have many a tale to tell!"

But if you're banned, you ain't talking to no one, are ya.~sntjohnny

Anthony Horvath

  • Administrator
  • sntjohnny? I'm sntjohnny!
  • *
  • Feedback: +28/-41
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8493
    • http://www.sntjohnny.com
Does 'Unconditional Love' Exist?
« Reply #19 on: October 27, 2005, 11:39:03 AM »

Your story is all good until the interpretation,

"He was the man. He was in charge"

You said a great deal in the story about the good intentions the father had.  Perhaps at some point, in mercy, the father may have decided to carry the child.  Or, perhaps the father, knowing his own child better then YOU know the child, would know that mercy here would convey yet another bad life lesson.  To know otherwise would require information not given to us in the story.  Was there evidence the girl would later on follow her father's good advice?  Things like that.

In your telling, the story has nothing to do with a man's need to be 'in charge' or 'manly' or 'authorative.'  The man sounds like a good father to me, teaching the following lessons in this account:

1.  People should not ignore the advice given by those with experience.
2.  If you make a decision, you need to be prepared to endure the consequences, as her father will not be around in perpetuity.
3.  Decisions DO have consequences.
4.  Decisions sometimes have consequences that have painful results, and not always to your own body- but feeling that pain at least in a minor way can serve as a vaccination against decisions where there is great pain that follows.
5.  Sometimes things that appear to be good, are not, and sometimes things ARE good, but only in the right context.

Humans are only as frail as you make them.  Your course of action would reduce the girl to a simpering little panzy the rest of her life, without the courage to make bold decisions, or even wussy ones, if her father is not around to wipe her little nose and wipe her lil' toosh.

This attitude has nothing to do with a father, or mother, wanting to be 'the man.'  Your interpretation has a word:  enabler.

Is that what you think love is?  Enabling destructive behavior?
Logged
Today's Favorite Quote:  "The UN is like GI Joe - an organization with the goal of world peace. Difference being one of them actually achieves their goals."  EndBringer

Yesterday's Fav: "I love when it all comes down to semantics, because that usually means I get to pwn someone."  Sir Somebody Something, Deep Truth, Trent, Solaris Paradox
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up